Early Math Skills

Isabelle: Mom? Can I have one more (mini) muffin? 

Isabelle's Mom:  Just one more.

Schatz (whispering):  You can have lots more if you want.

Me (sternly): Kaitlyn.  Don't you tell her that.  Isabelle's mommy said one more. If Isabelle's mommy says she can only have one, how many muffins can Isabelle eat?

Schatz (quietly): Three.

Me: Did you just say THREE!

Schatz:  Yes, Mommy.  She ate two and her mommy says she can have one.  That's three.